The Brescia Review cancels for the third time the seizure of Mario Venditti’s electronic devices in the investigations into the Pavia System. The lack of primary evidence weakens the accusations and puts the entire evidentiary system of the Garlasco case at risk.
Cell phones and PCs seized, or rather not. Or maybe yes. And instead he turned around in Pavia system: The Court of Review of Brescia he canceled for a long time third time the seizure of the electronic devices of the former deputy prosecutor of Pavia Mario Vendittias part of the investigations into Garlasco case. The decision, issued on November 16, 2025accepted the appeal presented by the defense lawyer Domenico Aiello.
Cancellation concerns eleven electronic devices seized on 26 September 2025, including phones, computers, tablets and hard drives, which will be returned to their rightful owner together with any data already extrapolated.
Decree “too generic”
The prosecutor’s seizure decree Claudia Moreregola dates back to 24 October, which was followed by the defense’s objection, because the keywords useful for analyzes on devices, aiming instead at one thorough search extended over eleven years. A previous annulment on 17 October had already judged the measure to be «too generic».
In the new reasons, the judges defined «incongruous» all the elements presented by the prosecution to support the hypotheses of corruption And embezzlement. And they highlighted the lack of concrete evidence: «Elements of corruption are missing» which demonstrate, for example, the private use of cars rented by the Pavia Prosecutor’s Office at the time under the guidance of Venditti.
The defense of the former assistant prosecutor will present a request to obtain restitution immediate of electronic devices, while the Brescia Prosecutor’s Office let it be known will recur in Cassation against the decision of the Review.
Unrepeatable verification
Although the cancellation provision is immediately effective, in fact, the devices remain temporarily in the hands of the prosecutors Bresciabecause a unrepeatable verification ordered by the Prosecutor’s Office on forensic copies of the contents: the technical examination is impossible to repeat due to the risk of alter or lose original digital data.
The decision also concerns the devices of the former Pavia carabinieri Giuseppe Spoto And Silvio Sapone. The latter was interrogated for seven hours in Brescia by prosecutors Claudia Moreregola And Chiara Bonfadiniagain regarding the Pavia System. Leaving the court he declared: «Nobody covered for anyone».
Effects on the Sempios
The cancellation of the seizure produces effects not only against Sold youbut also on the position of Giuseppe Sempio and his son Andrew. According to the prosecution, in 2017 the family Example had poured between the 20 and 30 thousand euros to Sold you to obtain the dismissal of the investigations against his son: the Brescia Prosecutor’s Office believes that Giuseppe Sempio personally managed the flow of money, as appears to emerge from the statements made by his wife Daniela Ferrariheard as a witness on 26 September.
But without any evidence present in the devices seized from Sold youthe accusatory system results significantly weakenedlosing the possibility of verifying whether there is concrete evidence of corruption linked to that filing.
Thus, the Brescia investigators are left with an accusation to support, but without the elements to prove it. A short circuit judicial system of the Pavia system and the murder of Chiara Poggi with in the center Andrea Sempio: Venditti’s electronic devices, seized and released for three consecutive timesrepresent the void into which the entire accusation risks falling.
